Anti-Fraud/Anti-Phishing Detection |
| Phishing Detection Comparison |
McAfee/Intel |
Proofpoint |
| Granular and configurable policies for phishing messages |
 |
 |
| Sender ID checks |
 |
 |
| DKIM checks |
 |
 |
| BATV checks |
 |
 |
| Header analysis checks |
 |
 |
| Machine learning technology for accurate content analysis |
|
 |
| Separate quarantine for phishing messages |
 |
 |
| Real-time notification and alerting of phishing messages |
|
 |
| Automated delivery of reports for phishing messages |
 |
 |
| Proofpoint uses advanced machine learning technology to detect phishing messages that pass through the techniques used by Intel's Email Gateway. Customers usually perform a threat assessment to compare phishing detection capabilities. While it depends on your mail volume, some customers have reported that Proofpoint was able to detect over 2,000 phishing messages that passed Intel's spam filters. |
Spam effectiveness |
| Spam Detection Comparison |
McAfee/Intel |
Proofpoint |
| Reputation-based spam detection |
 |
 |
| Header analysis |
 |
 |
| Configurable deny and drop lists |
 |
 |
| Image spam classifier |
 |
|
| Backscatter protection |
 |
 |
| Email connection throttling and termination |
 |
 |
| Email Zombie detection |
 |
 |
| Bayesian technology |
 |
|
| Machine learning technology |
|
 |
| Outbound spam detection |
|
 |
| Proofpoint uses advanced machine learning technology to granularly and more accurately detect spam (unsolicited bulk mail) and solicited bulk mail that pass through the techniques used by Intel's Email Gateway. Customers usually perform a threat assessment to compare spam detection capabilities. It depends on your mail volume, but some customers have reported that Proofpoint was able to detect over 600,000 spam messages that passed Intel’s spam filters. |
Virus effectiveness |
| Virus Detection Comparison |
McAfee/Intel |
Proofpoint |
| 100% Anti-virus SLA |
 |
 |
| Zero-Hour Anti-virus detection for zero-day protection |
 |
 |
| Anti-virus engine |
Authentium or McAfee |
F-secure or McAfee |
| Customers usually perform a threat assessment to compare virus detection capabilities. Depending on your mail volume, some customers have reported that over a two-week period, Proofpoint was able to detect more than 50 viruses that Intel's Email Gateway let through. |
Policies for email attachments |
| Policies for email attachments |
McAfee/Intel |
Proofpoint |
| Size of attachments |
 |
 |
| Binary file detection |
 |
 |
| Password protected files |
 |
 |
| Number of attachments |
 |
 |
| While these features are generally not enabled very often on most email gateway solutions, both Intel/McAfee and Proofpoint have similar capabilities here. |
Content filtering of email attachments |
| Comparison of Content Filtering Of Email Attachment Types |
McAfee/Intel |
Proofpoint |
| Microsoft Office 2003 files |
 |
 |
| Microsoft Office 2007 files |
 |
 |
| Microsoft Office 2010 files |
 |
 |
| Adobe PDF files |
 |
 |
| These features are important for an accurate email data loss prevention solution, and both Intel/McAfee and Proofpoint have similar capabilities here. |
Data Loss Prevention/Compliance |
| Data Loss Prevention comparison |
McAfee/Intel |
Proofpoint |
| Policy-based encryption |
 |
 |
| Pre-configured compliance policies for SSNs and all CCs |
 |
 |
| Pre-configured compliance policies for HIPAA, GLBA, PCI |
 |
 |
| Smart Identifiers – algorithmic checks of structured data |
|
 |
| Managed Dictionaries – pre-defined and updated libraries |
|
 |
| Advanced proximity and correlation analysis |
 |
 |
| Content rules based on regular expressions |
 |
 |
| Document training and fingerprinting for protecting digital assets |
 |
 |
| Optimized message decryption for mobile devices |
 |
 |
| End-user triggered encryption for sensitive data |
 |
 |
| Per-message encryption keys |
 |
 |
| DLP incident dashboard for administrative remediation |
 |
 |
| These features are important for a complete email data loss prevention solution, as accuracy, advanced encryption, advanced workflow tools are important to ensure that end users are not impacted and compliance officers have tools to investigate data loss incidents. |
Message Encryption |
| Message Encryption comparison |
McAfee/Intel |
Proofpoint |
| Transparent encryption (TLS or SSL) |
 |
 |
| Policy-based encryption |
 |
 |
| Secure MIME |
 |
 |
| Secure PGP |
 |
 |
| Push Encryption |
|
 |
| Pull Encryption |
 |
 |
| Optimized message decryption for mobile devices |
|
 |
| End-user triggered encryption for sensitive data |
 |
 |
| Per-message encryption keys |
 |
 |
| End-user revocation controls for encrypted messages |
|
 |
| These features are important for a complete email data loss prevention solution, as accuracy, advanced encryption, advanced workflow tools are important to ensure that end-users are not impacted and compliance officers have tools to investigate data loss incidents. |
Reporting and Log Search |
| Reporting and Log Search comparison |
McAfee/Intel |
Proofpoint |
| Same day reporting |
 |
 |
| Support for IPv6 |
|
 |
| Automated publishing, scheduling, and email delivery of reports |
 |
 |
| DLP Dashboard – consolidated view of compliance activity |
|
 |
| Log search delay |
Real-time |
Real-time |
| Log search by sender, recipient, and subject |
 |
 |
| Log search by attachment name |
|
 |
End User Functionality |
| Comparison of Features Available To End Users |
McAfee/Intel |
Proofpoint |
| Configurable end user quarantine pages |
 |
 |
| End user quarantine release |
 |
 |
| End user defined spam policies |
 |
 |
| Configurable end user whitelist |
 |
 |
| Per user regional and language settings |
 |
 |
| Self-remediation of outbound spam and DLP incidents |
|
 |
Platform |
| Comparison of Features |
McAfee/Intel |
Proofpoint |
| On-premise appliance |
 |
 |
| Virtual appliance |
|
 |
| SaaS |
|
 |
| Domain specific spam policies |
 |
 |
| Domain specific email routing |
 |
 |
| LDAP profiling/synchronization |
 |
 |
| Consolidated management of multiple appliances |
|
 |
| Consolidated reporting across multiple appliances |
|
 |
| Consolidated log searching across multiple appliances |
|
 |