Email Authentication

In today’s digitally connected world, email remains a critical communication tool for businesses and individuals alike. However, it’s also the primary vector for cyber threats, with over 90% of targeted attacks launched through email.

The threat landscape is evolving rapidly, with Proofpoint’s 2024 State of the Phish Report reporting an average of 66 million targeted Business Email Compromise (BEC) attacks every month. As cyber risks continue to escalate, with 69% of organisations experiencing a successful ransomware infection in the past year, the need for robust email security solutions have never been more apparent. Enter email authentication—a crucial line of defence against email-based threats that every organisation should implement.

Cybersecurity Education and Training Begins Here

Start a Free Trial

Here’s how your free trial works:

  • Meet with our cybersecurity experts to assess your environment and identify your threat risk exposure
  • Within 24 hours and minimal configuration, we’ll deploy our solutions for 30 days
  • Experience our technology in action!
  • Receive report outlining your security vulnerabilities to help you take immediate action against cybersecurity attacks

Fill out this form to request a meeting with our cybersecurity experts.

Thank you for your submission.

What Is Email Authentication?

Email authentication is a collection of techniques and protocols designed to verify the legitimacy and origin of email messages. It aims to confirm that the sender of an email is who they claim to be, thereby protecting both the sender’s brand and the email recipients from spoofing, phishing, and other malicious activities.

The process of email authentication involves validating the domain ownership of any message transfer agents (MTAs) who participated in transferring and possibly modifying a message. This validation helps email service providers fight spam and phishing attempts, determine which emails are legitimate, and ultimately protect email recipients.

Three primary email authentication methods work together to create a robust security framework: Sender Policy Framework (SPF), DomainKeys Identified Mail (DKIM), and Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting & Conformance (DMARC). By implementing these authentication protocols, organisations can significantly enhance their email security posture.

Authenticated emails are more likely to reach the intended recipient’s inbox, improving deliverability and protecting the sender’s domain reputation. Moreover, email authentication helps mitigate the risks of brand impersonation, reducing the chances of successful phishing attacks against an organisation’s customers or partners.

It’s worth noting that while these methods are powerful, they work best when used in combination. A layered approach to email authentication provides the most comprehensive protection against email-based threats.

How Email Authentication Works

Email authentication is a multi-step process that involves several protocols working together to verify the email sender’s legitimacy. Here’s a distilled breakdown of how it functions:

  1. Sender configuration: The domain owner sets up authentication records (SPF, DKIM, and DMARC) in their Domain Name System (DNS).
  2. Email sending: When an email is sent, it includes information about the sender and authentication details in its headers.
  3. Receiver verification: The receiving mail server checks the email against the authentication records published in the sender’s DNS.
  4. SPF check: The server verifies that the sending IP address is approved to send emails for the domain.
  5. DKIM verification: The server uses the public key in the DNS to decrypt the DKIM signature and verify the email’s integrity.
  6. DMARC evaluation: If SPF or DKIM checks fail, the server consults the DMARC policy to determine how to handle the email.
  7. Decision: Based on the authentication results, the receiving server decides whether to deliver, quarantine, or reject the email.

This process happens within seconds, providing a robust defence against email security threats while ensuring legitimate emails reach their intended recipients.

The Importance of Email Authentication

Implementing email authentication is crucial for businesses and organisations in today’s digital landscape. Here are the key reasons why email authentication matters:

  • Enhanced security: Such measures protect against phishing attacks and email spoofing, effectively reducing the risk of malware distribution through email and safeguarding sensitive information from unauthorised access.
  • Improved deliverability: Proper authentication increases the likelihood of emails reaching the inbox rather than spam folders while enhancing the sender’s reputation with email service providers and reducing the chances of blocking or filtering legitimate emails.
  • Brand protection: Email authentication prevents unauthorised use of your domain for malicious purposes. It also maintains customer trust by ensuring only legitimate emails are sent in your name and mitigates potential damage to brand reputation from email-based attacks.
  • Compliance and legal protection: Authentication meets email security regulatory requirements in various industries and provides a layer of legal protection by demonstrating due diligence in email practices, including compliance with regulations like GDPR and CCPA in protecting data privacy.
  • Analytics and insights: DMARC reports provide valuable data on email sending patterns and potential abuse, helping identify and address issues with email infrastructure and third-party senders.
  • Customer trust and engagement: Email authentication builds credibility with recipients, which means higher click-through and open rates while reducing the likelihood of customers falling victim to phishing attempts that impersonate your brand.

By implementing robust email authentication measures, organisations can significantly improve their email security posture, protect their brand, and ensure more effective communication with their audience.

Email Authentication Methods

Email authentication employs three primary methods to verify email sender legitimacy and protect against email-based threats: SPF, DKIM, and DMARC.

Sender Policy Framework (SPF)

SPF prevents email spoofing by specifying the authorised IP addresses that send emails from a domain. SPF adds a DNS record that lists approved IP addresses and mail servers. When an email is received, the receiving server checks if the sending IP matches those listed in the SPF record.

This protocol helps prevent phishing attacks and improves email deliverability by ensuring emails come from legitimate sources. SPF benefits include reduced chances of domain abuse, enhanced sender reputation, and improved overall email security.

DomainKeys Identified Mail (DKIM)

DKIM is a level-up that uses cryptographic signatures to verify an email message’s authenticity and integrity. It ensures that emails haven’t been altered in transit and confirms they originated from the claimed domain. DKIM adds a digital signature to the email header using a private key, which the receiving server then verifies using the public key published in the sender’s DNS.

This method provides stronger protection against email tampering and forgery than SPF alone. DKIM helps maintain the integrity of email content, improves deliverability, and builds trust with email recipients by allowing receiving servers to detect forged sender addresses in emails.

Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, & Conformance (DMARC)

DMARC builds upon SPF and DKIM, providing a framework for domain owners to specify how to handle authentication failures. DMARC allows senders to instruct email providers on whether to deliver, quarantine, or reject emails that fail authentication checks. It also enables domain owners to receive reports about messages sent using their domain, helping them monitor and improve their email authentication practices.

DMARC publishes a policy in the DNS that specifies how to treat emails failing SPF and DKIM checks. Its benefits include enhanced protection against phishing and spoofing, improved visibility into email streams, and the ability to enforce consistent email authentication policies across an organisation.

These three methods can work together to establish a robust email authentication system. While SPF and DKIM provide the foundational authentication checks, DMARC adds an extra layer of policy enforcement and reporting. Implementing all three methods significantly enhances email security, protects brand reputation, and improves overall email deliverability.

How to Implement an Email Authentication System

Implementing email authentication is a crucial step in securing your organisation’s email communications. Here’s a guide on how to set up an effective email authentication system:

Assess your current email infrastructure: Identify all sources of outgoing email, including marketing platforms, CRM systems, and third-party services. Map out your email-sending domains and subdomains.

  1. Choose an implementation approach: Decide whether to implement authentication protocols yourself or use a managed service provider, and consider your in-house expertise and resources when making this decision.
  2. Start with SPF: Begin by implementing SPF, as it’s typically the easiest to set up. Create and publish your SPF record in your domain’s DNS.
  3. Implement DKIM: Generate DKIM keys and configure your email servers to sign outgoing messages. Publish your DKIM public key in your DNS.
  4. Deploy DMARC: Start with a monitoring policy (p=none) to gather data without affecting email delivery and publish your initial DMARC record in your DNS.
  5. Test your configuration: Use email authentication testing tools to verify your setup. Send test emails and analyse their authentication results.
  6. Monitor and analyse: Set up a system to receive and analyse DMARC reports and leverage these insights to refine your authentication policies.
  7. Gradually tighten policies: As you gain confidence in your setup, move from monitoring to enforcement. Progressively tighten your DMARC policy from p=none to p=quarantine and finally to p=reject.
  8. Educate your team: Train relevant staff on email authentication principles and best practices and ensure your team understands the importance of maintaining these protocols.
  9. Maintain and update: Regularly review and update your authentication records as your email infrastructure changes and stay informed about new developments in email authentication technologies.

Email Authentication Best Practices

To maximise the effectiveness of your email authentication system, follow these best practices:

  • Regular monitoring and analysis: Continuously monitor authentication reports and analyse trends. Establish alerts for sudden changes or anomalies in authentication results.
  • Periodic policy reviews and updates: Review your SPF, DKIM, and DMARC policies at least quarterly and update policies to reflect changes in your email infrastructure or sending practices.
  • Comprehensive coverage: Ensure all your domains and subdomains are protected with authentication protocols. Don’t forget to authenticate transactional and automated emails.
  • Strict SPF records: Use “-all” in your SPF record to explicitly deny unauthorised sources. Avoid using “+all” or “?all” as they weaken your SPF protection.
  • Regular key rotation: Rotate your DKIM keys periodically (e.g., every 6-12 months) to enhance security and implement a process for smooth key transitions without disrupting email flow.
  • Alignment optimisation: Ensure proper alignment between your “From” domain and your SPF and DKIM domains. Strive for both SPF and DKIM alignment to maximise DMARC effectiveness.
  • Third-party sender management: Maintain an inventory of all third-party services sending email on your behalf and work with these services to ensure they properly authenticate emails using your domain.
  • Feedback loop implementation: Set up feedback loops with major ISPs to receive reports on spam complaints and use this information to improve your email practices and reputation.
  • Stay informed and adapt: Stay updated with the latest email authentication standards and best practices. Be prepared to implement new protocols or updates as they become available.
  • Documentation and process management: Maintain detailed documentation of your email authentication setup and policies and establish clear processes for making changes to authentication records.

These best practices help organisations establish a robust email authentication system that significantly enhances their email security posture and protects their brand reputation.

How Proofpoint Can Help

Proofpoint offers industry-leading solutions to simplify and streamline email authentication implementation, with a particular focus on DMARC deployment. As the trusted choice for more Fortune 1000 companies than the next five closest competitors combined, Proofpoint provides comprehensive support for organisations seeking to secure email communications.

Proofpoint’s Email Fraud Defense solution helps secure your email channel and restore trust to business communications. It simplifies DMARC authentication, helping to stop email fraud and safeguard your trusted domain. The solution goes beyond basic DMARC implementation by offering insights into supplier fraud risks and providing comprehensive domain discovery to detect lookalike domains attempting to impersonate your brand.

With Proofpoint, you can access world-class consultants who guide you through every step of your DMARC journey. Their expertise helps identify all legitimate senders, ensure proper authentication, and publish DMARC reject policies without blocking valid emails. Proofpoint also offers cutting-edge technology, including hosted authentication services for SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, which streamline management and improve security. Additionally, Proofpoint’s solution integrates seamlessly with its industry-leading secure email gateway, providing a holistic approach to email security.

By partnering with Proofpoint, organisations can confidently navigate the complexities of email authentication, protect their brand reputation, and ensure the deliverability of critical customer communications. To learn more, contact Proofpoint.

Ready to Give Proofpoint a Try?

Start with a free Proofpoint trial.